HEP Requirements Review 2020

Quick Links


The primary purpose of an ESnet Requirements Review is to discuss and analyze current and planned science use cases and anticipated data output of a particular program, user facility, or project to inform ESnet’s strategic planning, including network operations, capacity upgrades, and other service investments. The goal of this particular review is to accurately characterize the networking requirements of science funded by the HEP Program Office. These requirements will serve as input to the ESnet architecture and planning processes, and will help ensure that ESnet continues to provide world-class support for scientific discovery for DOE scientists and their collaborators. The tangible outcome of the review will be a document that includes both the network requirements and a supporting narrative. 

The Requirements Review is typically an in-person event. By design, it is meant to be a highly conversational process through which all participants gain shared insight into the salient data management challenges of the subject program/facility/project. The ESnet Science Engagement Team organizes, convenes, and executes the Review in close coordination with the ESnet Program Manager and one or more leads from the subject program/project/facility.

ESnet will focus the Review to deliver the following outcomes:

  • Identification and analysis of any data management gaps and/or network bottlenecks that are barriers to achieving the scientific goals.
  • A forecast of capacity/bandwidth needs by area of science, particularly in geographic regions where data production/consumption is anticipated to increase or decrease. 
  • Development of a shared understanding of the data management needs, challenges, and capability gaps that could inform strategic investments in solutions.

Review Objectives, Outcomes, and Artifacts

Through a cases study methodology, the Review provides ESnet with information about:

  • Existing and planned data intensive science experiments and/or user facilities, including the geographical locations of experimental site(s), computing resource(s), data storage, and research collaborator(s). 
  • For each experiment/facility project, a description of the “process of science,” including the goals of the project, how experiments are performed and/or how the facility is used. This description includes information on the systems and tools used to analyze, transfer, and store the data that is produced. 
  • Current and anticipated data output on near and long term time scales.
  • Timeline(s) for building, operating, and decommissioning of experiments, to the degree these are known.

  • Existing and planned network resources, usage, “pain points” or bottlenecks in transferring or productively using data the science produces.


Due to COVID-19 pandemic impacts, staging this event in 2020 as an in-person review will not be feasible.  The original plan was to stage this as a 2-day in person event, along with a High-Luminosity LHC planning meeting.  At this time we are working on options to hold a hybrid event virtually, with an eventual in-person gathering when it is safe to do so in 2021.  This schedule is subject to change:

Virtual Components

The following virtual deadlines and events have been tentatively scheduled:

    • Case study preparation by author teams: mid June through mid August 2020
      • Due Friday August 14, 2020
    • ESnet & DOE Review of case studies and production of summaries: mid August through September 2020:
    • 1:1 meetings (as needed): mid/late August 2020: 1:1 meetings (as needed)
    • “Focus Groups” to discuss case study findings: mid/late September 2020
    • Final Report draft released in November 2020
    • Discussion Webinars in November 2020
    • Final Report Published March 2021

Physical Components 

The following physical deadlines and events have been tentatively scheduled:

    • Physical Review: Fall 2021.  DC/MD

Review Registration

The review is by invitation only, and registration is not available at this time.  

Review Report

This review will generate a network requirements document for the HEP Program Office. This document will be composed of the network requirements input from the workshop attendees.

Review attendees should review the case study template document and other background materials on the documents page. Please also review the pages on the ESnet public web site. Please then use the background materials in combination with your own knowledge and experience, as well as input from representatives from your facility and laboratory, to generate a narrative describing your scientific research, instrument, facility or other scientific endeavor. Examples of science narratives with their accompanying requirements matrices can be found in the reports from previous reviews. Case studies (both the narrative and the corresponding data table) must be submitted to the review organizers (Jason Zurawski (zurawski @, Lauren Rotman (lauren @, Andrew Wiedlea (awiedlea @, Ken Miller (ken @, & Eli Dart (dart @

At the review we will review the documents and speak with the attendees to ensure that we understand the science being done insofar as it has an impact on networking. We will also make sure that we capture the timelines for upgrades, new facilities, changing collaborations, and other coming events that will change the way in which the network is used.

The review format is much closer to a round-table discussion rather than a series of PowerPoint presentations. If you feel that you really need to give a formal presentation we can accommodate that by providing a suggested template, but we have found that these review are more productive if there is a simple discussion and exchange of ideas rather than a formal presentation format.


The following rough schedule has been devised:

  • Webinars to introduce the Case Study format, and expected timeline
  • Case Study preparation (asynchronous) 
  • 1:1 Virtual discussions (expected Summer 2020)
  • Small "Focus Groups" to discuss Case Study findings  (expected Fall 2020)
  • Community Webinar to Summarize Findings  (expected Winter 2020 )
  • Final Publication (expected Winter 2021)
  • 1Year "Checkin" & Discussion (expected Summer 2021, potentially Physical Meeting)

This schedule is subject to change and will be finalized in Summer of 2020.  The location of the physical review portion is still being planned, and not available at this time.   


Information regarding parking will be posted when the physical venue is selected.  

Airport Info

There are two airports in Washington DC area, both are ~30miles from the possible physical venue:

  • Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport (DCA)
  • Washington Dulles International Airport (IAD)

Ground Transportation

Hotels typically do not offer shuttle service. Super Shuttle offers round trip service from the airport to the venue, as do local taxis, and Lyfts/Ubers.

Please let us know if you have any questions about travel logistics - we look forward to seeing you all at the event.

In-Person Agenda

The precise agenda has not been determined yet. 


There will be two webinars offered by the ESnet and DOE teams to discuss the HEP review process, the Case Studies, the expectations for participants, the associated timelines, and provide an opportunity to ask questions.

  • Monday June 8th @ 1pm ET. This event is targeted for people based in all US timezones. 
  • Thursday June 11th @ 9am ET. This event is targeted more for people based in the EU timezones, as well as ET in the US
  • Thursday November 19th @ 10am ET.  This event is targeted more for people based in the EU timezones, as well as ET in the US
  • Tuesday November 24th @ 11am ET.  This event is targeted for people based in all US timezones. 
    • Recording TBD

Dial in information for the webinar is as follows:

Join Zoom Meeting
Meeting ID: 973 0280 7218
One tap mobile
+13126266799,,97302807218# US (Chicago)
+16465588656,,97302807218# US (New York)
Dial by your location
+1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago)
+1 646 558 8656 US (New York)
+1 301 715 8592 US (Germantown)
+1 346 248 7799 US (Houston)
+1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose)
+1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma)
Meeting ID: 973 0280 7218
Find your local number:
Join by SIP
Join by H.323 (US West) (US East) (EMEA) (Canada)
Meeting ID: 973 0280 7218

Recordings will be made for those that are unable to make these times. All participants are encouraged to attend or listen to at least one of the webinars.